.17 HMR vs .22 WMR: Which Magnum Rimfire for Rabbits, Foxes and Cats

Choose the .17 HMR if most of your shooting is rabbits, hares and small vermin out to about 150 m in still air: it is the flattest-shooting common rimfire by a wide margin. Choose the .22 WMR if you want a rimfire for foxes and feral cats, or you shoot in open, windy country: its heavier 30 to 40-grain bullets hit harder and drift less. Both are Category A in a bolt action in NSW, both cost much more per round than a .22 LR, and neither is suitable for goats, pigs or deer.

The two "magnum" rimfires sit between the .22 LR and a centrefire such as the .223. Our .22 rimfire guide introduces both. This follow-up goes further: how they compare in the paddock, which ammunition to use, the rifles that come in both chamberings, and how to choose between them.

The two cartridges in brief

.22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire (.22 WMR, often just ".22 Magnum"). Introduced by Winchester in 1959. A longer, stronger case than the .22 LR, firing 30 to 50-grain bullets, with 40 grains at roughly 1,875 feet per second as the classic load. It is not interchangeable with the .22 LR in either direction.

.17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire (.17 HMR). Introduced by Hornady in 2002 by necking the .22 WMR case down to a .17-calibre bullet. A 17-grain bullet leaves at roughly 2,550 feet per second, which makes it much flatter than the .22 WMR over normal rimfire distances.

.17 HMR .22 WMR
Typical bullet 17 to 20 gr 30 to 40 gr
Typical velocity (factory) About 2,375 to 2,650 fps About 1,875 to 2,200 fps
Trajectory Very flat to about 150 m Drops noticeably past 100 m
Wind Light bullet, drifts more than you expect Heavier bullet, holds its line better
Best on Rabbits, hares, small vermin Foxes, feral cats, rabbits
Typical twist 1 in 9 1 in 16
NSW category (bolt action) Category A Category A

Velocity figures are typical published factory numbers and vary by load and barrel length. Twist rates are those listed on the rifles we stock.

Which one for which job

Rabbits and hares

The .17 HMR is at its best here. The flat trajectory means you can hold dead-on for head and chest shots across a typical paddock without working out holdover, and the fast, light bullet is very effective on small game. The .22 WMR does the job too, but needs more holdover past 100 m.

Foxes and feral cats

The .22 WMR is the more honest fox rimfire. Its heavier bullet carries more energy and penetrates better on a fox's chest, and it is less affected by a breeze. Keep fox shots close, ideally inside about 100 m, and pick a hollow point or soft point. The .17 HMR can take foxes with precise placement at short range, but its light bullet leaves little margin. If foxes are the main job, a centrefire such as the .223 is the better tool; see our fox control guide.

Windy, open country

This is where the .17 HMR surprises people. A 17-grain bullet at speed drifts a long way in a crosswind, and on a breezy afternoon the slower .22 WMR often lands closer to where you aimed. In sheltered gullies and on still mornings, the .17 HMR comes into its own.

Around sheds, stock and neighbours

Both are louder than a .22 LR. If noise and a short, safe distance matter most, a .22 LR with subsonic ammunition is still the right choice.

Goats, pigs and deer

Neither. Rimfires do not carry enough energy for them. Step up to a centrefire: see the .243 and .308 guides.

Ammunition

Rimfire rifles can be fussy, so buy a box or two of a few loads and shoot groups before you buy in bulk. From our shelves:

Full metal jacket rimfire bullets don't expand and are more likely to ricochet, so keep them for targets. Rimfire cases can't be reloaded.

Rifles that come in both

The easiest way to choose is to handle the same rifle in both chamberings. Several models we stock come in .17 HMR, .22 WMR and .22 LR on the same action:

Strong choices in one chambering:

Browse every .17 HMR rifle and .22 WMR rifle, or all rimfire rifles.

Scoping a magnum rimfire

A 3-9x or 4-12x scope with a 40 to 44 mm objective suits both. Parallax matters: a scope set for 100 m will show a small aiming error at 50 m unless your eye is perfectly centred, so an adjustable objective or side focus is worth having. Mount it as low as the objective allows. Our rifle scope guide covers the details, and a bipod or shooting sticks will tighten field groups more than extra magnification.

Field notes

  • Backstops. Both cartridges travel a long way. Never shoot at an animal on a skyline, and take care over water, hard ground and rock.
  • Cleaning the .17. The small bore needs a .17-calibre rod or pull-through. Clean the bolt face and chamber as well as the bore; see how to clean a rifle.
  • Heat. Keep ammunition out of a hot ute. Rimfire priming is sensitive to heat and age, and old, cooked ammunition is a common cause of misfires.
  • Zero for the load. A 17-grain and 20-grain .17 HMR load, or a 30-grain and 40-grain .22 WMR load, will not hit the same point. Re-zero when you change.

Licensing and buying in NSW

A bolt-action rimfire rifle is Category A in NSW, the broadest licence category. You still need a licence and a Permit to Acquire for each rifle, and since 1 July 2026 a safe storage inspection must be passed before a Permit to Acquire is issued. Our Permit to Acquire guide walks through the steps.

Magnum Sports, NSW Firearms Dealer Licence 413159984, keeps .17 HMR and .22 WMR rifles from Bergara, CZ, Tikka and Anschutz, with ammunition for both, at our Roseville Chase store. Ammunition is sold for in-store collection only, to holders of the appropriate licence, and we do not ship ammunition. Call (02) 9882 2689 or come in and compare them side by side.

Frequently asked questions

Is the .17 HMR or .22 WMR better for foxes?

The .22 WMR. Its heavier bullet carries more energy and drifts less in wind. Keep shots close, ideally inside about 100 m, or use a centrefire such as the .223.

Is the .17 HMR good for rabbits?

Yes. It is one of the best rabbit cartridges there is, with a very flat trajectory to about 150 m in still air.

Can I fire .22 LR in a .22 WMR rifle?

No. The cartridges are different sizes and are not interchangeable. Fire only the cartridge marked on the barrel.

Does wind affect the .17 HMR?

Yes, more than most people expect. Its light bullet drifts a long way in a crosswind, and on a windy day the .22 WMR often lands closer.

Can you hunt pigs or goats with a .22 Magnum?

No. A rimfire doesn't carry enough energy for goats, pigs or deer. Use a centrefire.

What licence do I need for a .17 HMR or .22 WMR?

A bolt-action rimfire rifle is Category A in NSW. You need a licence covering Category A, an accepted genuine reason, a passed safe storage inspection and a Permit to Acquire for the rifle.

Does Magnum Sports ship rimfire ammunition?

No. Ammunition is sold for collection only from our Roseville Chase store. Bring your licence when you collect.

General information, not legal advice. Confirm current firearms law with the NSW Firearms Registry. Ballistic figures are typical published factory numbers. Last checked 17 November 2026.